Editor's note: Click here for our latest comparison of cordless oscillating tools!
Pro Tool Reviews did its first corded oscillating multitool comparison shootout in 2009. This was one of my first comparison articles, and it's still popular among those looking to see what's available in the world of wired multitools. At the time, finding the best cordless vibrating multitool was a pipe dream—cordless multitools were just starting to hit the market—and most new models were 12V. Today's cordless multitools have come a long way, and the current 18-volt (presumably) models are impressive. For starters, these new tools have incredible runtimes. Run times are measured in the range of 10 minutes or less for most 12V cordless multi-tools. Now, your full-size cordless oscillating multi-tool can easily get the job done for over half an hour—albeit a little less.
How do you test and compare 18V cordless oscillating multi-tools?
I won't give it away, but it involves taking each model and running them directly through a series of tests. I chose Bosch MXH180BL, Fein MultiMaster AFMM 14, Makita LXMT025, Milwaukee 2626-22, Porter-Cable PCCK510LA, Porter-Cable PCC710, Ridgid JobMax R862004 and DeWalt DCS355D1.
Finding the best cordless vibrating multitool available today is important for a number of reasons. First off – there's nothing like them. When you need a cordless multi-tool, chances are it's because there's no other tool that does the job. This could be cutting into pipe that doesn't have a lot of side clearance, or it could be cutting a nice vertical cut into a piece of baseboard molding. I can't forget my personal favorite – the undercut jamb. I've cut dozens of door frames in the process of laying tile or wood floors, and the oscillating multi-tool has been my go-to tool for this type of work. It's so much better than any manual or other chainsaw type, and if I find myself running out of tools in the middle of a job, I'm more than happy to go pick up a new multi-tool. Doing it any other way is simply not worth the trouble.
Each of the tools tested in this review article has many similar features, but also some unique details. They're all 18V (nominal) models, with the exception of the Fein MultiMaster, which is 14.4 (but can certainly handle its own weight. With the exception of the Bosch MXH180BL and the Fein Multimaster, all tools include a handy LED light to illuminate the work area. Large Most tools also come in kits, but Ridgid's JobMax and Porter-Cable's 20V Max tools currently only fly individually, allowing you to add them to your collection at a much lower cost of entry.
There's nothing like cutting into hardwood floors. The oscillating multi-tool is a handy tool when you need to cut floor registries or cut areas to replace plywood for tile laying. The problem is that with older floors – the kind I run into most often – you're dealing with heart pine or even oak, which can lead to major cuts if you're doing more than just a few grooves challenge. For this test, I grabbed some 90-year-old heart-shaped pine floors and started researching which model was the best cordless vibrating multitool in its class.
test system
Establishing a fair and efficient testing method is no small challenge. You have to make sure your setup is designed to test the tool and not the add-on. You're going to have to go buy the blade after you've done some work, so tool reviews based on the included blade are pretty much worthless if you want to know how the tool will actually perform. For these tests, I used Porter-Cable blades. While the quality isn't great, they are OIS compatible, allowing us to test all the tools without plugging in any adapters. This means you can get even better performance if you accept our tests and results and replace with a quality accessory blade.
In order for these hardwood tests to be accurate and repeatable, a system that provides consistent force to the blade is needed – a system that is better than just using your hands. To achieve this, I constructed a 3 level leverage system with the help of reviewer David Delk. With a solid base and pivot on one side, and a 5-pound weight in the middle, we used 2.5 pounds to push the end of a 3/4-inch-thick heart pine plank into the blade of a stationary multitool (see diagram). The result is a consistent, repeatable test that can be performed repeatedly to average the results.
The test is simple: Which tool will cut through a board of old knotless pine the fastest? Each tool runs each test 3 times and uses a stopwatch to record the scores for each round. Finally, we average the results and record them in our table.
result
I have high hopes for Fehn to do well in this test. I have extensive experience with this tool. What I didn't expect was that it would be beaten by Makita – who turned out to be an invisible star player after another (read on). Most tools fall in the middle range, from 11-13 seconds. The bottom two tools are 20V Max Porter-Cable PCC710 and DeWalt DCS355. On average, the PCC710 took an astounding 68.7 seconds to slice through our board—a fact we attribute to its tendency to lose lateral movement when encountering significant loads. This reduces the cutting ability of the tool. (We also retested it with a different blade to make sure it wasn't an attachment.) When the Makita was tested, it had recorded a lot of mid-range tools, so imagine it biting through ours in just 8 seconds My astonishment seconds flat when boarding! Until I reset the test and run it two more times, I don't believe it won't just hit the soft part of the wood. In fact, its stellar score led us to retest all of the tools—but the results don't seem to have changed. When evaluating why some tools are better at cutting than others, it can be difficult to come up with a clear reason. At first, I thought the vibration might be the culprit – since smoother tools perform better in most cases. Another more obvious connection is swing angle. The Makita LXMT025 has an extra 0.2 degrees of wobble than most other tools (DeWalt shares this), which may be enough to cut material more aggressively. Also, the tool's ability to maintain that angle of motion even when cutting into hardwood (similar to how a drill maintains its maximum torque under load) seems to be a relevant factor.
Having already tested the corded vibrating multitool, I know there is nothing better than cutting into hardwood floors. But when you need to cut a piece of material that might have a nail embedded in it, it's good to know that your tool is up to the job. We decided to use the same wood/metal blade test tool to slice through two consecutive 16D galvanized nails driven into the test board. It takes some setup, but enough to reveal the tool's ability to handle the metal it encounters during cutting. We performed these tests on brand new blades using the hand-held method, as it is nearly impossible to eliminate reactive vibrations caused by the workpiece on small diameter nails. In the end, I believe our test configuration is good enough to compare tools in their class.
Overall, the nails added about 15-20 seconds to cutting time on average, which also matches our experience with freehand cutting of standing galvanized nails with the tool. Remember that plunge cuts like this are almost always faster when you vary the angle of the cut and keep the blade moving. Our testing involved a static tool position with only 2.5 lbs of downward force on the blade.
I still have some more objective tests to run, but handling these tools is another big part of what makes the best cordless oscillating multitools. Shock absorption is a huge thing with a tool like this, and it's clear who owns it and who doesn't seem to have prioritized it during development. We primarily test the vibration by handling the tool and giving a subjective opinion, but I also do a "pepper" test where I sprinkle pepper on a white piece of paper and drop the tool while it's running and observe the results (a test I can't do Execute on DeWalt or Ridgid because of the way they operate via triggers).
Both the Porter-Cable 20V PCC710 and the DeWalt DCS355 have plenty of vibration (and are two of the louder, higher-pitched tools in the roundup). On the PCC710, I love how you can choke on the head of the tool and really manipulate it. It almost feels like a barrel clamp puzzle. That's mostly because the power button is on the bottom of the tool (a bit awkwardly). I like being able to stand the DeWalt, Makita and Porter-Cable models vertically, although the 18V Porter-Cable has a lot of weight on the rear of the tool, making it off balance. The Milwaukee, Fein, Ridgid, and Bosch have almost perfect balance and balance, though the Bosch is incredibly square and a bit bulky unless you have big hands.
All 18V oscillating multi-tools have an integrated LED light, except Bosch and Fein models. Also, while the Ridgid JobMax technically has an LED, it's more optimized for the tool's drive head and can cast quite a shadow when using multitools and cutting attachments.
Of the best cordless vibrating multitools tested, only the Ridgid and Makita require tools to change accessories. Makita is at least thoughtful, offering tool storage for an Allen key. In the tool-free model, Fein took a while to get used to, but once I did, I really liked the way the system worked—especially since it didn't require any threads. The Bosch MXH180BL is easily the easiest tool to use, bypassing any other tool for easy accessory changes. The 2626-20 from Milwaukee is easy to use, but requires the center post to be unscrewed three full turns before it can be pulled out and the fitting replaced. The DeWalt and Porter-Cable models are very simple clamp-on mechanisms, but if you want to use non-slotted attachments, you're going to have to use an OIS style adapter and have to use an Allen key to hold everything in place. If you like Porter-Cable's slotted fittings, that's great, but this will definitely reduce your options. The clamp-on models also never seem to provide a flush fit for any of the accessories I've used the tool with.
I want to test the runtime of these 18V tools. After texting a few 12V models, the problem with cordless multi-tools has always been that you always (seem to) need a new battery. I can safely declare that those days are over. In my opinion, there's really no reason to buy a corded multitool if you're not working in a shop that requires absolutely constant runtime (or as light a tool as possible). The best cordless vibrating multitools last a long time. Anyway, what I did was run the tool with no load, but during testing I made sure to cut about 22" of 3/4" heart pine and 17.5" of heart pine 2×4 material with each tool . This puts some load on the tool, at least during testing, so it's not a pure idle battery comparison.
The results were somewhat unexpected. I thought the 4Ah battery would win handily, but the 3.0Ah Makita shut itself off after 50 minutes and 23 seconds, almost 16 minutes faster than the 4.0Ah Milwaukee! To sweeten the pot, charge the Makita in just 30 minutes, and then it's ready to go again. However, Ridgid JobMax ran in an astonishing 1 hour and 45 minutes (43 seconds). It's been running for so long that I don't want to do a runtime test again for the life of me. It's like the energy bunny… except it's orange…and has bigger teeth. The next closest contender was Porter-Cable, who ran just over 1 hour and 14 minutes. DeWalt gave inconclusive results because its protected mode started at about 10 minutes…and then started again 5 minutes later. I doubt you'll ever run an oscillating multitool continuously for that long, so it's hard to fault them.
Test 5: Noise Level
Given OSHA's regulations on occupational noise exposure in the workplace, it seemed like a good idea to test a multitool for maximum sound output. There aren't many surprises here, with all tools in the 88dB to 93dB SPL range. This means the tool is capable of making this level of noise when measured with a C-weighted SPL meter when measured from 36 inches away (we set it to slow response to ensure the output we hear is sustained ). Overall, the quietest tools were the Porter-Cable PCC710 (87 dB), the Ridgid JobMax (88 dB), and the Bosch MXH180BL (89 dB). The loudest tools are the DeWalt DCS355, the Milwaukee 2626-20, and the Fein MultiMaster AFMM 14 (all three have a measured sound pressure level of 93 dB). My general advice is that you should wear protective earmuffs or earplugs if you plan to use these tools.
in conclusion
Which multitool you choose will largely depend on your needs, but I couldn't help but be blown away by the Makita LXMT025. It has excellent runtimes, fast cutting speeds and great ergonomics. Of all the tools tested, it had the least vibration and the fastest charge time for the 18V battery. This is simply a great tool. In terms of ergonomics, the best cordless vibrating multitools are the Makita LXMT025, Bosch MXH180BL, and Porter-Cable 18V PCCK510LA because they are the easiest to use. They also exhibit minimal vibration, directing all cutting forces to the workpiece rather than your hands. I also like the improvements made to the Fein AFMM 14 MultiMaster, especially in terms of how well put together the tool is and its overall build quality – it's excellent (but you'll pay for it). The Bosch MXH180BL and DeWalt DCS355 are the only brushless multitools on the market that I know of, and the Bosch in particular feels like a solid machine. If there's any tool that follows directly Fein's "Mercedes-level" approach to design, it's the MHX180BL. In terms of absolute value, if you've already bought a 20V Max system, picking up the Porter-Cable PCC710 can't be beat. For just $69, you can get a tool that will get the job done. Of course, for around $199, you can get a brushless DeWalt DCS355D1 kit that includes a 20V Max Slim battery and charger, and is very comfortable to use—great value for money!
Bosch MXH180BL
The Bosch comes across as a well-built but boxy tool that feels exceptionally large in the hand—I don't see that as a comfort asset. It's one of only two brushless models (the other being the DeWalt DCS355D1), and one of the easiest attachment/blade swaps on the market. It uses "spreaders" instead of fixed pins or threaded rods. Turns out, this is the fastest tool for changing blades. I'd even go head to head with Porter-Cable's clamp system. There are no LEDs on this tool, so keep that in mind if you tend to work in dimly lit areas.
- Pros : Brushless, well made, quickest/easiest parts replacement, fast cutting
- Cons : No LEDs, bulky, expensive, sold without batteries or charger
- Price : $329
Verdict : This is a Mercedes-Benz multitool priced like a Volkswagen but with a Volvo look .
Fein AFMM 14 MultiMaster
Fein is the second fastest tool of its kind, after Makita. The short length makes it very easy to steer and use. It's also a pleasure to hold in the hand, with smooth edges but a strong grip. The tool-less blade release is difficult to operate at first, but once you get used to it, you can quickly change accessories. Expect to pay $150+ more than any other multitool in this group.
- Pros : Built like a tank, easy/quick parts replacement, well balanced, fast cutting
- Cons : No LEDs, very expensive, very loud
- Price : $499
Verdict : If you want the most expensive, well-made cordless multitool you can buy, this is it.
Makita LXMT025
I don't want to insult Makita by saying I'm surprised by how well this tool works, but it clearly took our team by surprise during testing. The Makita LXMT025 has about half the vibration of most other tools, making it almost a joy to use. It runs long and takes less time to charge the battery than any other 18V tool (which is good since the company refuses to add a battery fuel gauge to its tools). With the fastest cutting speed of any tool tested, this tool is our overall leader. It's also one of four tools that can stand upright (the others are the Porter-Cable PCCK510, 20V Max PCC710, and DeWalt DCS355).
- Advantages : fast cutting speed, low vibration, fast charging time
- Cons : No battery gauge.
- Price : $299
Verdict : The overall leader in our test… there is no other way to express it.
Milwaukee 2626-22
The Milwaukee 2626-20 is a solid tool with ergonomic fit. It is easy to operate and the blade change mechanism is simple to use, but requires unscrewing a set bolt. The tool vibrates a lot compared to some others, and we were surprised by its slower cutting speed and runtime performance. It's also a very long tool at 16-1/2" from the blade (second only to the Ridgid which is nearly 17" long. The Milwaukee runs very hot and the blade and retaining ring heat up significantly during use.
- Pros : Good ergonomic feel, quick accessory changes
- Cons : Slow speed, high vibration, mediocre run time
- Price : $319
Verdict : A good choice for those already on Milwaukee's M18 platform, but for those looking for the best performing multitool, there are better options out there.
Porter Cable PCCK510LA
This tool is still sold with the newer 20V Max models, but it has some notable flaws. It's very heavy on the back of the tool, so it wants to lean back against you during use. While the tool-less fitting system is nice, if you want to buy any non-Porter-Cable (OIS) fittings, you'll end up having to use tools. I also found it really odd that the tool didn't grip most accessories (including Porter-Cable's own). The LED lights are perfectly placed on the work area, and the tool stands upright (despite being tilted back a lot) very well.
- Pros : Inexpensive, well-placed LEDs, placed vertically
- Cons : No battery gauge, awkward balance
- Price : $129
Verdict : This is an average multi-tool that you can get for a fraction of the price and can be used on just about anything.
Porter Cable PCC710B 20V Max
The 20V Max version of the Porter-Cable Oscillating Multi-Tool has improvements over the previous model, such as losing the dramatic back tilt (it's now upright, perpendicular to the battery). Beyond that, you get a new housing, and the power switch has been moved to the bottom of the handle so you can choke on the tool if needed. Because of that, and with a nice finger locator near the top, the tool feels very nimble in the hand. Grips are great for jigsaw puzzles because you almost want to try some curve cuts!
- Pros : Great ergonomics, super cheap
- Cons : Slowest cutting tool, strong vibration, awkward switch position
- Price : $79
Verdict : If you have any Porter-Cable 20V Max tools, you'd be crazy not to pick it up because it's less than $80.
Ritchie JobMax R862004
Because it's built on the JobMax platform, the R862004 (along with the DeWalt DCS355D1) uses variable-speed triggers instead of fixed-speed dials. LED lights are better suited for JobMax drive tools than this head. The tool's ergonomics are excellent, and it has the narrowest, most comfortable handle of any tool tested (except maybe the DeWalt tool). The running time for this tool is an exciting 1 hour and 45 minutes!
- Pros : Incredible run time, fast cutting, great ergonomics, great value
- Cons : No variable speed dial, no kit options
- Price : $99
Verdict : This is a great all-around tool that can also be used with Ridgid's other JobMax bits (right-angle drills, impact drivers, miter saws, jig saws, etc.).
DeWalt DCS355D1 Max 20V
The DeWalt DCS355D1 is the only other brushless tool on the market, but it feels like Ridgid JobMax had an affair with Porter-Cable and produced more capable offspring than the parents. We like its cutting speed, handling and the included attachment for setting the depth of cut. The brushless motor (the only other tool that advertises an EC motor is the Bosch MXH180BL) means you should be able to use this tool for years.
- Pros: Powerful cutting, brushless motor, perfect ergonomics, great value for money
- Cons: No variable speed dial, loud, overheat protection mode
- Price: $199
Verdict: Priced $100 or more less than most other kits, DeWalt is making inroads into the remainder market with this impressive brushless tool.
